Fascinating tools you come up with!

My input to kiro-cli:

using ~/git/cppalliance/tools-public/tools/wg21/arno.md please review P3832.md and P3833.md as a whole. (those .mds are in https://github.com/bemanproject/timed_lock_alg/tree/main/papers if you're interested to see what it had to work with)

=== Response from Arno:

Done. The report is at arno-p3832r4a-p3833r4a.md.

Summary of key findings:

1. No conclusion section (high) — Neither paper has a funnel-out. Delegates who skim to the end get no restatement of the ask or significance.

2. No explicit ask in abstracts (medium) — Both abstracts name the contribution but don't state what they want from the committee.

3. Unprepared sections in P3832 (medium) — Sections 3 and 4 open with bare bullet lists, no framing sentences.

4. P3833 try_lock_until underspecified (medium) — The multi-mutex case says "similar to lock()" without stating whether it delegates to P3832's free function or specifies its own algorithm.

5. P3833 destructor exception semantics (medium) — The design discussion says it "may throw" but the wording doesn't address this, and the destructor is implicitly noexcept.

The papers are otherwise solid: self-contained, well-calibrated for the audience, terminologically consistent, and the wording is production- quality. The missing conclusion is the most impactful gap — everything else is fixable with a few sentences each.

I've attached arno-p3832r4a-p3833r4a.md but I haven't read it thoroughly myself yet. It's too hot in Gothenburg to start the brain right now :)

Br, Ted

2026-06-27 00:31, Vinnie Falco via Delegates:

So, we've been doing these paper reviews and Arnaud Becheler gave this wonderful review:

https://lists.wg21.org/archives/list/paper-reviews@lists.wg21.org/message/35...

I took his post, turned it into a set of actionable bullets using Claude, and then I asked Claude to build a tool which can write papers like this, and also evaluate a paper against his criteria. I call it:

*The Arno* https://github.com/cppalliance/tools-public/blob/master/tools/wg21/arno.md

I'm revising P4003 based on it!

Thanks

---

Delegates mailing list -- delegates@lists.wg21.org To unsubscribe send an email to delegates-leave@lists.wg21.org https://lists.wg21.org/mailman3/lists/delegates.lists.wg21.org/ Archived at: https://lists.wg21.org/archives/list/delegates@lists.wg21.org/message/FA6D4B...